Fans of Siesta Key are no strangers to Cara Geswelli’s evolving relationships.
From dating fellow cast members to stepping away from the show’s central drama, Cara’s love life has long been a topic of interest. One name that keeps resurfacing is Michael Wheary.
Speculation about whether the two are married has been circulating for some time. But despite the assumptions, there is no confirmed evidence that Michael Wheary is Cara Geswelli’s husband.
Cara Geswelli’s Dating History
Cara first gained attention on MTV’s Siesta Key for her involvement with castmates like Alex Kompothecras and Garrett Miller. Those storylines often centered around conflict, betrayal, and emotional breakdowns.
Her relationship with Michael Wheary, however, has been notably more private and stable, offering a stark contrast to her earlier reality TV romances.
Michael Wheary entered the picture in 2021. Their relationship became public when Cara mentioned him during Siesta Key Season 4, though he never played a major on-camera role.
Still, his presence was acknowledged, especially in scenes where Cara opened up about their dynamic.
By April 2022, it was widely reported that they had already been dating for about two years. While the show focused less on them as a couple compared to others, their relationship appeared to be steady and maturing quietly in the background.
Who is Michael Wheary?
Michael Wheary is not a public figure in the entertainment world, but he does have a solid personal and professional history.
A former athlete, Wheary played wide receiver in the Canadian Football League after attending Southeastern University and Youngstown State.
His athletic background often appears in discussions of his personality, as he is described as disciplined, competitive, and goal-oriented.
After retiring from football, Wheary moved into the corporate world. He worked for a range of companies, including Worldwide Express, CR Bard, and most recently, Comp360.
These roles span sales, medical technology, and pharmaceutical fields, indicating a shift from athletics to business operations. His transition from sports to corporate life mirrors a pattern seen in many former athletes, but he’s remained largely out of the spotlight.
Although he has an active social life, Michael maintains a low profile online. His Instagram occasionally features snapshots of fishing trips, travel, and outdoor activities, but nothing extravagant or suggestive of influencer-style branding.
His low-key presence stands in contrast to the reality TV fame of his partner.
Are Cara and Michael Married?
As of July 2025, there is no credible evidence that Cara Geswelli and Michael Wheary are married. There have been no wedding announcements, marriage licenses, or formal public statements to suggest that they tied the knot.
While some social media posts casually suggest that they are still together, no footage from Siesta Key showed an engagement, wedding planning, or any references to a ceremony.
After the show ended in early 2023, the couple stepped further out of the spotlight, and since then, no new relationship milestones have been publicly documented.
Most outlets, including Distractify and E! News, still refer to Michael as Cara’s boyfriend.
They’ve chosen to keep most of their relationship details private, which naturally leads to speculation.
But based on everything available from credible sources, their status remains that of a dating couple, not a married one.
Life After Siesta Key: What We Know
Following the wrap-up of Siesta Key, Cara and Michael seem to have focused more on their personal lives away from television.
They are believed to be living in Florida, possibly in the Tampa area, based on Instagram location tags suggesting that they are building a shared life.
There is also no indication that they have separated or broken up. Their relationship appears to be stable, though quiet. They no longer post frequently together, but that seems more about maintaining privacy than signaling a split.
With Siesta Key no longer airing and the couple opting to stay off reality TV, there are fewer opportunities for the public to track their status in real-time.